
I discovered the Buttonhole Wheel Cup while experimenting with buttonhole wheels. I am sure I just re-invented the stitch, and somewhere someone else will have had the same thoughts.
They make great middles to flowers like daffodils, and I use them all over the place in my textured embroidery, as I really like working them. I think I find it appealing because they are so highly textured.
How to make the stitch

To work them, you need to know how to work a buttonhole wheel and then combine them with detached buttonhole. Both of these stitches are found in my stitch dictionary.
Start with working a buttonhole wheel. Space the spokes of the wheel fairly close together, but not packed. If your wheel edge flips up, it is probably because you are not spacing the stitches closely enough together.
Bring your thread out on the edge of the wheel and work a detached buttonhole stitch. I changed the thread colour so you can see what is happening, but normally I would have the same colour thread.
Into the edge of the buttonhole wheel, work buttonhole stitch. Do not work the stitch through the fabric, but around the edge of the wheel. One row will produce a ridge.

Two rows produce a small cup, and three rows, a deeper buttonhole wheel cup, and so forth. You can stitch beads to the middle of the cup or leave it as a textured stitch.

If you want the cup to go straight up, don’t add any stitches. If you want it to flare a little, add an extra detached buttonhole stitch every two or three stitches. To do this, work two stitches into the same hole the same way you would with crochet or knot stitches.
I hope you enjoy this stitch!
My book for creative stitchers

If you enjoy my site you will gain real value from my book: Creative Stitches for Contemporary Embroidery: Visual Guide to 120 Essential Stitches for Stunning Designs
Feeling stale? Wondering how to add sparkle to your embroidery? I have aimed Creative Stitches for Contemporary Embroidery to be suitable for both beginners and seasoned embroiderers. It introduces techniques to encourage your creative interpretations of stitches. I guide you towards discovering play-points in your embroidery by varying the height and width; by stacking stitches; or by filling multiple rows with the same stitch. With creative variations and demonstrations of tiny tweaks, You will be ready to head off down your own creative path and, of course, illustrated with plenty of eye candy!
Return to the Stitch Dictionary Index page

This is a new stitch to me. Thanks for introducing this textured stitch. My samples are here.
http://hobbysewing.blogspot.com/2020/09/tast-13-beyond-tast-13.html
2018 TAST Stitch #41: https://www.thecrafties.com/2018/12/tast-roundup-3/
I had never done anything like this, and now I feel like possibilities are endless! I can attach items that can’t normally be sewn; I can give texture and depth; I can make stumpwork motifs – I will also be coming back to this stitch!
-C
I am so pleased you like it – I think it is a fun stitch
I welcome the challenge.
Due to some health issues and personal issues, i have not some stitches. But sure will try soon.
Thankyou dear for doing this challenge. You make my days pretty. Yes everyweek i am so eaqur to see what will be the stitch this week. I enjoy all the fellow stitches and sometime wounder to see their creations and imagination. Really really i like this to be continue….
Pl. go ahead dear.
viji
Hi Sharon,
I did this buttonhole wheel stitch sampler today and have posted the details on my blog-
http://jizee6687.wordpress.com/category/tast-2012/43-buttonhole-wheel-cup-stitch2/
Thank you,
Chitra
Please don’t stop TAST !
http://stitchinfingers.ning.com/profile/JeanneMarieMellor
I especially Love, Love, Love this Buttonhole Cup Stitch!
Since I was running behind 3 weeks, I decided to make a combination sampler page. This started out as a page for Beaded Hedebo Stitch, but I realized if I continued with making a page for each stitch I will never catch up. I’m glad I made this decision because these stitches were wonderful worked together. I did a block for each stitch alone and then the rest of the page combining the stitches.
I textured the needle-felted tree with Hedebo Stitch, Italian Border Stitch and used the Buttonhole Cup Stitch to make the knots on the tree trunk. Then I used Knotted Loop Stitch for the leaves.
I have to say, I do love all the stitches, but I especially love the dimensional stitches. I can hardly wait for some free time during the holidays to make a piece combining drizzle stitch, cast-on, stitch, buttonhole cup stitch, etc., etc., etc.! And Sharon, I really, really love your ideas for TAST 2013!
i had a good time with this stitch~!~and created something a bit ghoulish to add to one of my recently created fabric postcards.
http://simpletosublimepapernapkinpoetry.blogspot.com/2012/10/happy-halloween.html
thanks again sharonb for the fun and interesting stitch challenge.
🙂
libbyQ
A sweet stitch, here are my samples of Buttonhole Wheel Cup stitch
http://debbies-doings.blogspot.ca/2012/10/tast-week-43.html
Hi Sharon, I agree with Anneliese’s sentiments about you bringing this amazing stitching community together. We have made some wonderful friends all over the world with the TAST challenge and Stitchin Fingers. Thank you.
After a big gap in my TAST stitching you can finally see my sample of buttonhole cup stitch here: http://dinkydideequilts.blogspot.com.au/2012/10/is-it-flame-tree-finally-some-tast.html
Regards Dianne.
My Buttonhole Wheel Cups:
http://textileexplorations.blogspot.de/2012/10/tast-2012-buttonhole-wheel-cups.html
I liked the Buttonhole Wheel Cup, and I also caught up with the Italian Border Stitch. A little pressed for time, so it’s short and sweet.
http://berrybakewell.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/tast-2012-weeks-42-and-43-italian.html
I have finished week 43. Buttonhole Wheel cup was interesting. http://timeusebybernice.wordpress.com/
I have enjoyed doing the stitches and learning the ones that were new to me this year. I have had to put other projects on hold in order to keep up so won’t be continuing in 2013. Thanks so much for a fun year.
I really appreciate the effort you make to teach us new stitches. I don’t think that we will ever bore of the opportunity to learn ways to make our work more unique! Thank you so very much for your more than generous shaing of your talent.
I used this stitch on a project I’m working on and to finish my rust dyed sampler. I wrote about it on my blog:
http://fat-quarter.blogspot.nl/2012/10/buttonhole-wheel-cups.html
The complete rust dyed sampler is here:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/28957501@N04/8131327782/in/photostream
and if anyone is keen to do something every week they can do both of course 🙂
ps ** Idea Alert **
I’ve just read through the other comments while i was opening the links to look at all the pretty things. I had an idea. What about running two parallel TASTs. If we imagine a four week month and if there’s a fifth Tuesday it’s a catch up week. Then of the four weeks, week one and week three could be TAST Buds for budding needleworkers going through fairly basic stitches so that those who learned them for the first time this year and just did a little sampler can do a little project this time round, and those who are new can join in easily. The featured items would be published two weeks later on the Monday just before setting the new TAST Buds. The alternate weeks, two and four, would be TAST Blooms for those blooming stitchers who want a bit more of a challenge to learn more new stitches, combinations of stitches and build on what they’ve learned this year. Their featured work would be published two weeks later, the day before the next TAST Blooms challenge.
xx Liz xx
Liz I will be announcing a few changes to TAST for next year – its in draft now and some ideas similar to yours will be included. I want to keep it is simple (people dont read directions about challenges as it is – to complex we lose them!) but the idea of duel challenge, more break weeks and yet a steady supply of stitches is included.
Dear Sharon, I’m loving TAST. One a week is perhaps a bit much. I’d quite like to do one a fortnight. Even if you do the same again I think I’ll have another go as I enjoy the stimulus to push myself to improve and the fun of the little competition. Thank you for the work you put into it all. xx Liz xx
Button hole wheel cups. One straight up, one decreasing in inside one increasing out. Using hedobo buttonhole stitch cos I like the extra texture it gives and scallops for the increasing one cos flat seemed a bit dense. Free button hole stitch covered bead. Hedebo edge stalks. Hope you like them.
http://stitchinfingers.ning.com/photo/daisy-daisy?context=user
Hi Sharon,
Just wondering how you finish the stitch?
Thanks
Here is my attempt
http://pierrespapiersciseaux.blogspot.fr/2012/10/tast-43-coupe-au-point-de-feston.html
About your question, the TAST is very interesting but takes a lot of time. I would like perhaps only one stitch every two weeks, or more often catch on weeks.
I am thoroughly enjoying the whole website and seeing what other stitchers are doing, It is exciting: and it is invigorating. I may not partake in TAST as I have a lot else going on and am obviously, not as young as I used to be.
I do not know how you accomplish so much anyway. Count me in as appreciative.
My few samples are posted at
http://crazyqstitcher.wordpress.com/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/stitchinwoman/8128771875/in/photostream
My buttonhole cups for week 43 – oh, I am in time!
Hi Sharon,
Though i could not actively participate in the stitch challenge I always like the ideas stitches and how well they are implemented in the designs by the participants. It is fun and also a good learning..I really enjoy TAST ..
Here is my new and old trials on buttonhole wheel cups..
http://sadalas.blogspot.in/2012/10/tast2012-week43-buttonhole-wheel-cup.html
My buttonhole wheel cups stitching is here…
http://ceoriginals.blogspot.com/2012/10/tast-buttonhole-wheel-cups.html
I won’t be doing anymore large tags this next year, but the more I think about it if I can come up with something simple to do for TAST next year I may try to do it…at least try the new stitches.
Thanks for all you do Sharon.
I stitched some Buttonhole wheel Cups and find its a very interesting stitch!! And I really would like to learn more next year….. this challenge is inspiring!
http://6stem5.canalblog.com
Hi Sharon, I made flowers….again.
I also used a catch up stitch: sheaf stitch.
http://threads-and-patches.blogspot.com/2012/10/tast-week-43-buttonhole-wheel-cup.html
Hello
My sample for the buttonhole wheel cups is here:
http://dufall.blogspot.com/2012/10/tast-semaine-43-buttonhole-wheel-cups.html
Sharon – if you continue with TAST in 2013 I will try to keep up. I love learning the new stitches and every weekly stitch-bit keeps my design juices flowing.
Thanks for the inspiration, Laurel
I like buttonhole cups, Thank you for sharing, Sharon.
Here is my attempt: http://fabricfusion.blogspot.co.at/2012/10/take-stitch-tuesday-week-43-und-zwei.html
Cheers Claudia
Here is my sampler for week 43.
http://eclecticlamb.com/2012/10/26/week-43-buttonhole-wheel-cups/
Hi Sharon……ignore last comment !
hugs
Chris R
xx
Hi Sharon, sorry to be a nuisance but I cant seem to upload any photos on stitchin fingers ……….is there any problems with the site ?
hugs
Chris richards
xxxxxx
Hi Sharon, thank you for asking, I appreciate it so much! Nancilyn’s suggestion sounds great. Why not combine it with the tast for a small design and watch after 3 – 4 weeks how we all will have worked it out in different ways?
Sharon it was very nice to you to share your experience in stitching during all the year. I think I shall complete my stitches’book at the end of 2012 and try to use some of the learned stitches in new projects. If you continue this great challenge, I shall not participate, but shall continue to learn the sitches I like. Thanks for all you do.
Here you can see my weekly sampler
http://j-en-revais.blogspot.com/2012/10/tast-43.html
Hi Sharon, great to be back………I love your buttonhole cups,
here is my sample for week 43 !
http://ellascraftcreations.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/buttonhole-wheel-cupstastweek-43.html
hugs
Chris richards
xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Here is my example of this week’s TAST challenge, Buttonhole Wheel Cup. The variations in form with different threads is interesting. I plan to explore how other threads form the ‘cup’.
http://stitchinfingers.ning.com/photo/at-the-fair-unfinished?context=user
Oh – I also tried turning the thread in different directions, knotting it differently, when stitching the detached buttonhole onto the buttonhole wheel.
~ L